For this Monday’s blog, I read the
article Teaching English Language
Learners: Strategies for Overcoming Barriers by Sara R. Helfrich and Amy J.
Bosh. The main purpose for this article was to identify four perceived barriers
for both beginning and veteran teachers. It wanted to take a look into what
educators face when teaching literacy to English language learners.
Specifically, the article addresses the teacher’s inability to differentiate
instruction to meet the needs of all learners, the devaluation of peer
interactions and collaborations in the process of learning a language, and a
lack of knowledge about using assessment measures with diverse student
populations. Finally, this article provides the audience with ways to overcome
these barriers as well as strategies for becoming an effective teacher.
To begin
this blog, I thought I would briefly mention some of the statistics they found
about English language learners. First, the population of ELL students jumped
from 6 million to nearly 14 million in 1999 according to the National Center
for Educational Statistics (Klein et al. 2004). Spanish is the most frequently
spoken language at 71%, followed by Asian languages at 11%, other non-European
languages at 10%, and other European languages at 7%. “A record of 55 million
students were enrolled in public and private elementary and secondary schools
across the nation in Fall 2006; an 8 percent increase in this number is
expected by the year of 2018” (Hussar and Bailey 2009). Thus, as you can see,
the number of English language learners is continuing to increase each year,
which means teachers must be well-prepared for the obstacles ahead. Rather than
striving for assimilation, teachers should strive for acculturation.
The first
barrier the article mentions states that teachers may not understand the role
of literacy development or the importance of literacy and education in diverse
cultures. One of the ways to improve this situation is to determine cultural
priorities and acquire background knowledge to help support the inclusion of
all students. In simple terms, teachers need to get to know their students and
where they come from in order to be effective teachers. For me, this is
especially important since I will be teaching in an urban multicultural
setting. It will be my job to figure out ways to overcome these challenges;
therefore, my goal will be to incorporate English as much possible into the
school curriculum without downplaying the students’ cultural background. A
great way to do this is to have certain “culture days.” It is important for
students to embrace where they come from, so celebrating various traditions,
foods, customs, etc. in English is a perfect way to do this. In addition,
teachers need to address other cultures in their literary sections.
The next barrier for teachers argues that they
may struggle to meet the literacy needs of all learners in their classroom,
especially those of ELLs. To overcome this barrier, teachers should work to
engage ELL students in classroom instructional activities without isolating
them or taking instructional time away from other students. While doing this,
teachers need to model how to speak the English language, use explicit
instructions, and real reading to convey meaning as well as increase the students
overall comprehension. Simply put, students need to be able to make meaningful
connections in order to achieve their full academic potential. This becomes
extremely difficult for ELL students because they have to do two things at
once. They are having to decode and interpret the English language while trying
to comprehend the literary material at the same time. Therefore, it is
important to give these students a chance to gather their thoughts (“wait-time”)
and provide them with authentic activities.
The third
barrier states that teachers should not underestimate the role of peers in the
inclusion and education of ELL students. Teachers should use partner-share,
group activities, peer tutoring, and use other ELL students whose knowledge and
use of the language is further progressed than the other ELL students. I
personally am a big fan of peer-collaboration because I believe students
oftentimes explain the material better than the teachers. Not only does this
give the more progressed ELL students a chance to practice the English
Language, they get to practice how to behave in social situations. One thing to
remember is that teachers should group ELL students with other English-speaking
students as well as other ELL students. One thing to remember is that these
students need to feel included in order to succeed. The worst thing teachers
could do is make them feel isolated; therefore, the article suggest that peer assistance
is a great way to overcome this barrier.
The final
barrier argues that teachers may not feel condiment when using assessment and
progress-monitoring tools with ELL students. I know this is something I
struggle with because I want to be fair to all students. One thing the article
suggests is that teachers should not be hesitant to use assessment and
progess-monoitoring tools. They should use oral questioning, numerous of discussion
opportunities, as well as other adapted forms of assessment. Teachers need to
make sure the assessment tools they use are reliable and valid and make sure
they accurately portray the ELL student’s knowledge. One thing I like to do is
create portfolios for my students. I feel these show their true progress, and
students always like to see how far they have come at the end of the year. Another
thing teachers should do is constantly assess their students; this is the only
way to get an accurate view of how well the ELL students are doing in the
classroom. In conclusion, yes, teachers have a lot to overcome with ELL
students; however, I believe it can be done. This is something that I will have
to work on, which is why I enjoyed reading this article.
Madelyn,
ReplyDeleteIt seems like this article was very interesting! Next year for my internship I will be working at Lenoir City Elementary School and a huge percentage of the students there are ELLs. I think it is very important to be able to connect with students in some way, even if you may not be able to connect with them through spoken language. I like the point of the second barrier about not isolating the students, but it seems like many schools are not working to do this--unfortunately. Many students are taken out of the classroom setting for a large portion of the day. I think portfolios are a great way to physically show the progress a student has made--and I never thought about using that for an ELL student, but what a great feeling to see how much of a language you have learned through the school year! I agree that working with ELL students (or really any student that is different from yourself) can be a challenge, but it is definitely something that can be done!
--Ciera Rinck